Review for week 28 - by Bill
In week 28 we were off to ["The Black Olive"](http://www.black-olive.com) in Tewksbury MA to take advantage of their Tuesday night meal deal: dinner for two and a bottle of wine for $30! We weren't so bold as to take pictures in the restaurant, so we'll be making due with some stock footage borrowed from the restaurants website. Fear not, John's exquisite wine bottle photography will return again next week!
The wines (3)
no photo
Wine #1$19.00
1.60 / 2.003 buy
Wine
2003 Gini Chianti Italy
Original heading: “2003 Gini - Chianti Italy”
This Chianti was fine. Not great, fine. The menu lists it at $19, which we figured translated to a $6 or $7 bottle and we hit this one on the nose. For the shelf price this is a fair buy. Subtle cherry, good color, not much of a finish but an easy drinker that will go with lots of meals. It's not going to blow your socks off, but we've had much worse Chianti's for much more money. Bring it to a party - most people will find it agreeable.
no photo
Wine #2$24.00
1.40 / 2.002 buy
Wine
2002 Masciarelli Montepulciano Italy
Original heading: “2002 Masciarelli - Montepulciano Italy”
$24 in the restaurant, $6.99 off the shelf. Our reviews assumed a $10-$12 price tag, and may have suffered a bit from that. Pleasant but not distinctive. Spicier than the Gini, but you're not going to find a lot of depth of flavor with this one. Another mild, easy drinker. No tats, no piercings as Ssezi would say.
no photo
Wine #3$32.00
1.40 / 2.002 buy
Wine
2003 Villa Trasqua Chianti Classico Italy
Original heading: “2003 Villa Trasqua - Chianti Classico Italy”
Another Chianti, this one a bit higher on the price scale. $32 in the restaurant, $21.99 off the shelf - A reasonable restaurant markup in the grand scheme. This one gave a bit more punch and depth of flavor than the previous offerings, with some spice and cherry. While it was universally thought to be the more interesting of the wines we sampled; I found it a little too bitter for my tastes.
Food (7)
no photo
Course #1
Food
Chicken Marsala with Ziti and Extra Marsala Sauce $14.95
Original heading: “Chicken Marsala with Ziti and Extra Marsala Sauce - $14.95”
Lacked the strength of flavor I seek in a Chicken Marsala, even after requesting extra sauce. A pleasant enough meal but I'd probably opt for one of the other entrees next time around.
no photo
Course #2
Food
Lasagna with side of Meatball $11.95.
Original heading: “Lasagna with side of Meatball - $11.95.”
Huge. "No human way I could eat the whole thing." If you like big portions this is a good idea. John found the lasagna to be too heavy on pasta and lacking a bit on the cheese and meat department. Even so, John enjoyed it quite a bit and would purchase again.
no photo
Course #3
Food
Lamb Kabob with Grilled Vegetables and Garlic Mashed Potatoes $16.95.
Original heading: “Lamb Kabob with Grilled Vegetables and Garlic Mashed Potatoes - $16.95.”
"Excellent." Ssezi ordered it medium and it was cooked appropriately. A great, light summer dish.
no photo
Course #4
Food
Chicken Marsala with Ziti, minus the shrooms $14.95.
Original heading: “Chicken Marsala with Ziti, minus the shrooms - $14.95.”
Rich quite enjoyed the marsala sauce but didn't feel there was enough of it. Good sized portions and tasty. Rich would order with extra sauce next time around but would buy again.
no photo
Course #5
Food
Chicken Skewers $13.95.
Original heading: “Chicken Skewers - $13.95.”
Nicely prepared, subtle flavors and a light dish. This meal was just what Ed was looking for and it delivered.
no photo
Course #6
Food
Chocolate Overload
Original heading: “Chocolate Overload -”
Chocolate cake with a light chocolate mousse and dark chocolate mouuse with whipped cream. An incredible desert - light with good chocolate, highly recommended.
no photo
Course #7
Food
Coffee, Decaf
Original heading: “Coffee, Decaf -”
Ed was downright tickled with the presentation of this coffee: A spoon and a white mug with plenty of cream and even some sugar. (oh my! listening to this audio I think perhaps we shouldn't have let Ed out of the parking lot...) Could anyone ask for a better way to bring the dinner to a close? Ed couldn't!
Generally I felt The Black Olive did a solid job of picking safe and pleasant wines. Safe and pleasant isn't a bad thing when going out for a reasonably priced dinner with friends. In a more presumptuous restaurant I'd have considered the safe wine selections a bit of a disappointment, but here they simply match the friendly atmosphere and help follow through with the restaurants mission of providing a consistently enjoyable experience.
The two meals and a bottle of wine deal for Tuesday nights is a nice bargain for $30, but note that you don't automatically get two entrees for that price - you receive a credit of $12 for each entree, and only a couple of them on the menu can be had for $12. Given the entree credits, the $19 wine essentially sets you back $6; which conveniently enough is the market price for these wines. This basically gives you an opportunity to have a nice dinner out and get one bottle of wine with your meal for the actual street price - which is far from common. If you choose, you can put your $19 wine credit towards a more expensive bottle, but in my opinion you're getting the best value by sticking to the cheaper wines on the menu... For instance, the Meeker Merlot will run you $85, which is a $55 markup over the street price. Your $19 credit doesn't put much of a dent in that and you're back to getting raped by restaurant wine prices no matter how you cut it. This level of mark-up is of course not specific to the Black Olive, but if you've been lured in by what is a nice wine & dinner deal, you're not doing yourself any favors by climbing the price ladder.
Overall the group gives the Black Olive an "Eat and Buy" for fair prices, good service, above average food and a selection of enjoyable wines that won't break the bank.
This marks our first but not last restaurant field trip, and although handling the audio in the restaurant was a bit awkward we had a fun time and hope you enjoyed sharing the experience with us!